1965 to 1968: Rev. Walter R Keim
1958 to 1964: Rev. C.C. Moore
1944 to 1957: Rev. Samuel A Kistler
1940 to 1943: Rev. John L. Reiner
1938 to 1939: Rev. R.A. Laubach
1913 to 1938: Rev. W.K. Fisher
1911: Rev. M.H. Stettler (Supply Pastor)
1897 to 1910: Rev. H.C. Kline
1896 to 1897: Rev. M.H. Stettler (Supply Pastor)
1884 to 1896: Rev. O.D.Miller
1866 to 1883: Rev. T.T. Yeager
1823 to 1866: Rev. G.F.I. Yeager
1816 to 1823: Rev. F. Engel
1811 to 1816: Rev. John Knoske
1803 to 1810: Rev. Daniel Lehman (Assisted by Rev. John Knoske)
1778 to 1803: Rev. Daniel Lehman
1775 to 1777: Rev. H. Moeller
1771 to 1775: Rev. Daniel Schumacher
1765 to 1771: Rev. John Andrew Krug
1763 to 1765: Rev. Daniel Schumacher
1759 to 1763: Rev. Bernhard Michael Hausihl
(His pastorate began at least 2 years before the church was built)